Skip to content

Apgar and Silverman-Andersen: assessing the newborn

The two key neonatal scores: Apgar (adaptation at birth, more points is better) and Silverman-Andersen (respiratory distress, more points is WORSE).

Advertisement
Reviewed by the MIROTECA medical team · November 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement

Apgar: adaptation at birth

The Apgar score assesses the newborn's adaptation with 5 signs (heart rate, respiratory effort, tone, response to stimulation and color), at one minute and at five minutes. Each is scored 0 to 2, for a total of 0 to 10: the higher, the better.

Silverman-Andersen: respiratory distress

The Silverman-Andersen score assesses the newborn's respiratory distress with 5 signs (nasal flaring, grunting, retractions, xiphoid retraction and thoracoabdominal dissociation). Here the direction is reversed: the more points, the WORSE (more respiratory difficulty).

The key difference

It is the error asked about most: with Apgar, more points is better; with Silverman, more points is worse. A newborn with a Silverman score of 0 breathes without difficulty; with 10, there is severe distress.

Exam questions and rounds

The two scales run in opposite directions: a high Apgar is good, a high Silverman is bad. Apgar measures overall adaptation (and should not be used to decide on resuscitation, which is guided by heart rate and breathing); Silverman measures respiratory difficulty.

Common mistakes when applying them

▶ Play today's clinical case