Which to use for bedside prognosis and which to prioritize liver transplant.
Two scores coexist in liver cirrhosis: Child-Pugh and MELD. Both measure severity, but they are used for different things.
It combines five parameters (bilirubin, albumin, INR or prothrombin time, ascites and encephalopathy) into three classes: A, B and C. It is easy to calculate and estimates prognosis, but it includes two somewhat subjective data: ascites and encephalopathy. See the Child-Pugh calculator.
It uses only three laboratory values (bilirubin, INR and creatinine), all objective. It predicts short-term mortality and is the basis for prioritizing the liver transplant list. See the MELD calculator.
Child-Pugh gives classes A, B and C and includes subjective data; MELD gives a number, from laboratory values only, and is used to prioritize transplant. If the question is about organ allocation, the answer is MELD.
Both are still used: Child-Pugh for a quick assessment and MELD (and variants such as MELD-Na) for transplant decisions. In the United States, liver allocation has used MELD 3.0 since July 2023, which adds sex, sodium and albumin to the original MELD.
The contrast is that both measure the severity of cirrhosis, but with different approaches: Child-Pugh includes "subjective" variables (ascites and encephalopathy) and classifies into A-B-C, whereas MELD is purely objective (bilirubin, INR and creatinine) and is used to prioritize the transplant list. Two ideas that round it off: including creatinine in MELD reflects that kidney function (hepatorenal syndrome) weighs heavily on prognosis, and MELD-Na adds sodium because hyponatremia worsens survival. In practice, the essential point is to tell compensated from decompensated cirrhosis (ascites, encephalopathy, variceal bleeding, jaundice), which is the real prognostic step.
▶ Play today's clinical case← All articles · Medical score calculators · Versión en español