Barthel, Lawton, SPPB and the rest, put in order.
The assessment of the older adult uses many scales and it is easy to get lost. The key is knowing what each one measures and in what order abilities are lost.
The Barthel Index and the Katz Index assess the basic activities of daily living: eating, bathing, dressing, moving. They are the most elementary functions and the last to be lost. Barthel gives a score from 0 to 100; Katz, a letter from A to G. See the Katz ADL index.
The Lawton scale measures instrumental activities: cooking, shopping, handling money or medication, using transport. They are more complex tasks that are lost before the basic ones, so Lawton detects decline earlier. See the Lawton IADL scale.
The SPPB measures leg performance (balance, gait speed and rising from a chair) and is one of the best for detecting frailty. The Tinetti scale assesses gait and balance to estimate the risk of falls.
The picture is completed with the Pfeiffer or the Mini-Mental (cognition), the Yesavage (depression, see the Geriatric Depression Scale), the MNA (nutrition) and the Norton or Braden (risk of pressure ulcers, see the Braden Scale).
Functions are lost in an order: first the instrumental (Lawton) and then the basic (Barthel and Katz). So, in an older person who is still independent for the basics but already failing at the instrumental, the alarm should go on: it is early decline.
The key to this topic is knowing what each scale measures in order to choose it. For basic activities (bathing, dressing, eating): Katz and Barthel. For instrumental activities (cooking, shopping, handling money and medication): Lawton and Brody, which are altered earlier because they are more demanding. For cognition: Pfeiffer and Mini-Mental; for mood: Yesavage; for the risk of falls: Tinetti; and for nutrition: MNA. The underlying idea is comprehensive geriatric assessment: combining the functional, cognitive, affective, nutritional and social to decide, rather than going by chronological age. Frailty (with sarcopenia at its core) predicts falls, dependence and mortality, and is largely reversible with strength exercise and nutritional support.
▶ Play today's clinical case← All articles · Medical score calculators · Versión en español