One looks at displacement; the other, at the angle of the fracture line. And how they change treatment.
Fractures of the femoral neck are very frequent in older adults. Two classifications are often asked about and easily confused: Garden and Pauwels.
Four types: I (incomplete or valgus-impacted), II (complete, non-displaced), III (partially displaced) and IV (completely displaced). It is the most used to decide treatment. See the Garden classification. Look at the trabeculae: in type IV they run parallel to those of the acetabulum again.
Three types according to how vertical the fracture line is relative to the horizontal: I (less than 30°), II (30-50°) and III (more than 50°). The more vertical, the more unstable and the greater the risk of nonunion. See the Pauwels classification.
The practical rule with Garden: non-displaced fractures (I-II) are usually fixed with osteosynthesis; displaced ones (III-IV) in older adults are treated with a prosthesis, because of the high risk of avascular necrosis of the femoral head.
Confusing them: Garden measures displacement (I to IV) and Pauwels the angle (I to III). They are not the same.
Both classify the femoral neck fracture, and the point is not to mix them up: Garden looks at displacement (I-IV) and Pauwels at the angle of the fracture line with the horizontal (I-III; the more vertical, the more unstable). What decides treatment is above all Garden: non-displaced fractures (I-II) are treated with osteosynthesis (screws), and displaced ones (III-IV) in older adults with arthroplasty (prosthesis), because of the high risk of avascular necrosis of the femoral head (its blood supply is retrograde and precarious). In a young patient, a displaced fracture is an emergency to reduce and fix and save the head. As with any hip fracture in an older adult, early surgery and comprehensive assessment matter, because mortality at one year is high. Trick: Garden = displacement, Pauwels = angle.
▶ Play today's clinical case← All articles · Medical score calculators · Versión en español