Skip to content

Pupillary defects: Argyll Robertson, Marcus Gunn and Adie

Reviewed by doctors · Last reviewed: November 2026▶ Play today's clinical caseMedicinedle · a Wordle-style case game · free
Advertisement
Advertisement

La pupila de Marcus Gunn (defecto pupilar aferente relativo) se dilata al iluminarla en la prueba de la linterna oscilante, mientras que la de Argyll Robertson no responde a la luz pero sí a la acomodación.

Chart of three pupillary defects: Argyll Robertson with no response to light but yes to accommodation, Marcus Gunn with paradoxical dilation on the swinging flashlight test, and Adie tonic pupil
⬇ Download the diagramView full size⬇ Download as PDF

Free to use for study and teaching with attribution to MIROTECA · terms of use

The key is the response to light and to accommodation.

More diagrams: UIP/IPF vs NSIP · Spinal (intradural) vs epidural anesthesia · Urinary casts and the disease each one points to

What the chart shows

Three classic pupillary abnormalities have a very characteristic examination that can be used to localize the lesion. The chart sets them side by side: the Argyll Robertson pupil, the Marcus Gunn pupil (relative afferent pupillary defect, RAPD) and the Adie tonic pupil.

The detail that settles it

The Argyll Robertson pupil, seen in neurosyphilis, does not react to light but does react to accommodation ("it accommodates but does not react"). The relative afferent pupillary defect (Marcus Gunn pupil) appears in optic neuritis: with the swinging flashlight test, when the affected eye is lit the pupils dilate paradoxically. The Adie pupil, typical of a young woman, is a dilated pupil with a slow response and associated areflexia.

Memory aid: "accommodates but does not react" points to Argyll Robertson (syphilis); a swinging flashlight with paradoxical dilation points to Marcus Gunn (optic neuritis); a tonic mydriasis in a young woman with areflexia points to the Adie pupil.

In exam questions

Questions usually describe the light and near responses and ask which defect it is and what disease or lesion it points to. Reading the response to light and to accommodation is enough to tell the three apart.

Keep practicing

This page is the visual summary. To test yourself with real clinical reasoning, Medicinedle, a Wordle-inspired game, gives you one clinical case a day: guess the diagnosis in six tries, with a new clue after every miss. It is free and available in English.

Play today's case →

Advertisement

Related

See all medical diagrams