Skip to content

Colles fracture vs Smith, Barton and Chauffeur fractures

Reviewed by doctors · Last reviewed: November 2026▶ Play today's clinical caseMedicinedle · a Wordle-style case game · free
Advertisement
Advertisement
Chart of distal radius fractures: Colles with dorsal displacement, Smith with volar displacement, Barton intra-articular rim fracture and Chauffeur fracture of the radial styloid
⬇ Download the diagramView full size⬇ Download as PDF

Free to use for study and teaching with attribution to MIROTECA · terms of use

The direction of the distal fragment, and whether the fracture enters the joint, give the name.

More diagrams: Scaphoid fracture · Pauwels classification · Salter-Harris classification · Bosniak classification of renal cysts

What the chart shows

The Colles fracture is the best-known distal radius fracture: extra-articular, with the distal fragment displaced and angulated dorsally. Seen from the side, the wrist shows the classic "dinner fork" deformity. It follows a fall on an outstretched hand with the wrist extended and is especially common in older women with osteoporosis. It is named after the Irish surgeon Abraham Colles, who described it in 1814.

The chart compares it with its "neighbors": the Smith fracture, with volar displacement (the "reverse Colles"); the Barton fracture, an intra-articular fracture of the dorsal or volar rim with carpal subluxation; and the Chauffeur or Hutchinson fracture of the radial styloid.

What to look at on the X-ray

On the posteroanterior and lateral views, radial inclination, volar tilt and radial height are assessed. Approximate normal values are about 22-23° of radial inclination, 11-12° of volar tilt and 10-13 mm of radial height, although they vary with the population studied.

Articular step-off weighs most on the outcome. As a guide, reference texts consider radial shortening of more than 5 mm, dorsal angulation of more than 20° or extensive dorsal or intra-articular comminution as signs of instability.

Complications that are asked

Late rupture of the extensor pollicis longus tendon, interestingly more common in minimally displaced fractures; median nerve compression (acute carpal tunnel syndrome); complex regional pain syndrome; and malunion.

In exam questions

Short rules: dorsal is Colles, volar is Smith; an intra-articular rim fracture is Barton; the radial styloid is Chauffeur. An older woman falling on an outstretched hand is the typical Colles case. See also Garden classification and Salter-Harris.

Keep practicing

This page is the visual summary. To test yourself with real clinical reasoning, Medicinedle, a Wordle-inspired game, gives you one clinical case a day: guess the diagnosis in six tries, with a new clue after every miss. It is free.

Play today's case →

Prefer quick questions? The clinical scores quiz gives you 5 case-based questions in about a minute, with the answer explained.

Advertisement

Related

See all medical diagrams